Last battles became very personal. I know who is high value target to kill, weak sides of the characters contesting me, importance of each my kill just but nickname. Same about enemy knowing about me (especially because people who were playing with me play for enemy). It's stupid to not use such information if you can, but in the same time it affects gameplay by e.g. ability to concentrate fire at character just because you know him.
I'm not sure if it's good or bad. I'm trying to imagine what will happen if enemy characters won't have nicknames real until you e.g. point mouse over it.
I expect same effect as not having 50 green numbers of players HP on the screen (other servers). It's lame.
Immersion for komrade, problems for concentration of the fire for organized teams, less personal pvp.
How to replace nicknames:
2 approaches:
a) Nothing until mouse over player
b) [Faction identifier] [rank in the faction (fame)]. E.g. V-tec noob, family warlord.
Ideas?
For sure, I agree, I like the idea of it based on level or reputation or fame, or all of the above. I still think it should hover over head (otherwise people with no wall mods are in a huge advantage, and everyone would probably use them or get trolled) without forcing the player to look at them.
Only your faction mates should know your name really.
Though with that being said, the game will be a lot more impersonal. For example "hey guys its actually me" blam blam blam "oh shit sorry all I saw was the vtech rapist label", or "nooo we just lost to a swarm of vtech noobs! And we have no way of seeking vengeance other than murdering indiscriminately".
So, good sides and bad, but you are right, as is, the person who knows or gathers the most personal and build information, is the better off party at the end of the day.